keskiviikko 28. lokakuuta 2026

Bernard Bolzano: Study of science – Heuristics

The ultimate aim of Bolzano’s Wissenschaftslehre or logic is the division of the whole field of human knowledge in disciplines, thus, he thinks it important to investigate how truths are discovered. Then again, he adds, logic should concern only with such heuristic rules that relate to thinking and its general applicability, because these are often of use in making scholarly treatises, while rules about, for instance, the proper use of senses fall out of its scope. Bolzano divides these rules into general rules applicable to all science and particular rules applicable to many, but not all kinds of investigation: we shall follow him in this division and leave the particular rules to the next post.

Before going to the general rules, Bolzano investigates the notion of thinking or meditation (Nachdenken in German). Commonly, he says, thinking means any series of representations and judgements, but Bolzano does not find this a good definition, since representations and judgements are constantly going on in our minds, even when we are not actively meditating anything. Thus, Bolzano excludes from the realm of meditation any stream of representations and judgements that are generated with no help of our will, like impressions caused by external objects. Even when our will has an influence, it is not meditation, he adds, if the aim is something else than just generating a certain species of judgements, for instance, when we seek satisfying representations (even dreamers do such things).

Meditation requires, Bolzano explains, that we awaken in ourselves representations and judgements with a definite and conscious purpose that we finally arrive at a judgement which has a certain characteristic: for instance, when someone tries to convince themselves that a judgement is true or when someone calculates something. Furthermore, he adds, if we are speaking of a pure mediation, the means by which our will generates the representations and judgements must be of a certain kind, so that our thinking is not influenced by the perceptions of external objects. Still, Bolzano contends, even pure meditation cannot be completely removed from all physical interaction, because the effect of the will on our representations is always mediated by our body. Then again, he notes, pure meditation cannot use the body as means, since bodily observations are not meditation.

Bolzano finally comes to the conclusion that pure meditation can be conjoined with unconscious influence on the body and even on other bodies: think of a person in deep concentration, who is mumbling or tapping their foot unconsciously. Thus, he explains, in meditation we generate, with nothing more but this possible unconscious interaction with the external objects, representations and judgements that we require to arrive at a judgement we search for.

Logic, Bolzano explains, is especially interested in meditation that is primed for searching for truth: in other words, meditation in logic tries to find an answer to some question. He divides truth searching meditation into recalling, where the truth is already familiar to us, but not just present in our mind, and discovery, where the truth is new and unknown (just to us or even to all humans). discovery; it is indifferent whether the truth is unfamiliar just to us or also to all humans). Furthermore, he defines speculation as meditation, where the truth that is searched and the propositions that we observe for the sake of finding the truth are conceptual propositions.

The actual rules Bolzano suggests are, as he himself admits, nothing original. Thus, he says, we should choose what kind of truths we want to search, since we can know only a finite number of truths. Furthermore, Bolzano notes, some questions cannot even be answered, and if it can be done easily, we should first check this possibility. Indeed, he adds, often we must solve a set of preliminary questions, before we can answer the primary question.

As for the actual methods of discovery, Bolzano mentions first the direct method, where we move forward from truths we already know through inferences and – hopefully – arrive at the answer we are searching for. The other possibility is an indirect method, where we construct a proposition that might be the truth that we are looking for – a hypothesis – and test whether it really is true. Indirect method, Bolzano explains, has many subspecies, such as apagogical method, where we start from a negation of the assumed truth and try to derive absurdities from it, analytical method, where we start from a hypothesis and test its possible grounds, and induction, where we test a sufficient number of instances of the hypothesis and determine at least that it is probable. He also notes that often only one method is not enough, but e.g. direct method must be used in conjunction with some form of indirect method.

This would exhaust the scope of pure meditation, but Bolzano still includes some rules that are commonly useful in investigating problems. Thus, he notes the usefulness of experiences, both those that we hear from reliable witnesses and those we have made ourselves. Furthermore, Bolzano reminds the reader of the importance of testing occasionally even judgements we have earlier deemed to be true and of analysing their reliability, although he notes that we cannot really do the so-called Cartesian doubt, since testing always requires assuming some judgements as criteria. Bolzano also emphasises the role of attention in guiding our thinking, of the capacity to use signs to give our thoughts more stability, of mental images in making our thoughts more vivid and of logical analysis to help us make inferences from our judgements.

Ei kommentteja:

Lähetä kommentti